top of page
Search

Email Metrics That Matter: How to Measure Success Without Losing Your Mind

  • Writer: Jonathan Eyres
    Jonathan Eyres
  • Sep 16
  • 2 min read

Updated: Sep 23


Colorful 3D bar graph on a chart with text: "Email Metrics That Matter, How to Measure Success Without Losing Your Mind."

Here’s the deal: email marketing gives you tons of data. Open rates, clicks, unsubscribes, bounces, heat maps, device stats—you name it. But drowning in numbers won’t help you sell more. The trick is knowing which metrics actually matter and what to do with them.

Let’s cut through the noise.

1. Open Email Rate: The Door Opener

  • What it is: Percentage of people who opened your email.

  • Why it matters: Tells you if your subject line and timing worked.

  • The catch: Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) automatically preloads emails, inflating opens. Meanwhile, Outlook sometimes blocks images, underreporting them. In short: open rates are more directional than exact.

  • Benchmark: 20–30% is solid for most industries.

    Glowing blue door ajar in dark room, revealing giant envelopes on a bright screen-like surface. Shadows cast on the floor.

2. Click-Through Rate (CTR): The Engagement Test

  • What it is: Percentage of people who clicked a link in your email.

  • Why it matters: Shows if your content and CTA actually interested them.

  • Watch out: Some corporate firewalls and security tools auto-scan links, which can slightly inflate CTRs.

  • Benchmark: 2–5% is healthy, but varies by industry.

  • Pro tip: Test one CTA per email—multiple links confuse readers.

3. Conversion Rate: The Real MVP

  • What it is: Percentage of people who took the desired action (purchase, sign-up, download).

  • Why it matters: This is where the money is—it proves ROI.

  • Benchmark: Varies wildly, but 1–5% is common.

  • Action step: Always connect email clicks to landing page analytics to track sales or sign-ups.

4. Unsubscribe Rate: The Gut Check

  • What it is: Percentage of people who said “no thanks” and bailed.

  • Why it matters: High rates mean your content isn’t relevant—or you’re emailing too often.

  • Benchmark: Under 0.5% is normal. More than that? Time to rethink.

    Woman in a blue shirt smiles at her phone, sitting by a laptop and coffee in an office with a leafy plant. Man in the background on a call.

5. Bounce Rate: The Silent Killer

  • What it is: Emails that couldn’t be delivered.

  • Why it matters: Hurts your sender reputation and deliverability.

  • Types:

    • Soft bounce: Temporary (like a full inbox).

    • Hard bounce: Permanent (bad address).

  • Action step: Clean your list regularly. A messy list is a marketer’s nightmare.

Vanity Metrics to Ignore

  • Total sends: Quantity doesn’t equal quality.

  • Forward rate: Fun, but doesn’t predict sales.

  • Time spent reading: Interesting trivia, not a business driver.

    Hands interact with a glowing smartphone. Envelopes symbolizing emails float upwards, set against a gray background, conveying digital communication.

How to Actually Use These Metrics

  1. Spot patterns: Don’t freak out over one bad send—look at trends.

  2. Test & improve: Use A/B testing to tweak subject lines, CTAs, and send times.

  3. Segment smarter: Compare metrics across audience segments to see who’s really engaging.

  4. Align with goals: If your goal is sales, conversions matter more than opens.

  5. Account for privacy & security effects: Remember that open and click metrics can be skewed by Apple MPP, image blocking, or link scanning. Use them as guideposts, not gospel.

Final Thoughts

Measuring email success doesn’t have to feel like deciphering ancient hieroglyphics. Focus on open rates, CTR, conversions, unsubscribes, and bounces—then act on what you learn. Keep in mind the quirks of email security and privacy changes so you don’t misinterpret the numbers. The rest? Nice to know, but not worth the brain space.

Next Up: We’ll wrap the series with Building Your Email Marketing Strategy: A Step-by-Step Guide—so you can put everything together into a plan that actually delivers results. New articles every week at The Ultimate Guide to Digital Marketing: Strategies, Trends, and Best Practices.

bottom of page